After bragging about each other's sugar-babies for a bit, Penny reveals that HER sugar-baby stayed the night. In fact, she can hear her stirring upstairs... Would Lexi like to meet her? Lexi says that she'd LOVE to, so Penny calls her sugar-baby, Natalie Brooks, downstairs. But when Natalie comes into view, Lexi and her are shocked to see each other, since Natalie just happens to be Lexi's STEPDAUGHTER! To make matters worse, Penny's stepdaughter, Chloe Surreal, comes home from work and immediately recognizes Lexi, who happens to be her SUGAR MAMA! Oh no... this can't be happening... Penny and Lexi's sugar-babies are each other's stepdaughters! What are the odds?!
All four of them try to sit down and diffuse the situation, but it only ends up making things more awkward. Having had enough, Natalie runs off to Penny's room, with Penny following her in desperation. Lexi lingers for a moment, but then runs off to follow Penny and Natalie, leaving a stunned Chloe downstairs. But when Lexi stumbles into Penny's room, she finds Penny and Natalie making out! Wow- the nerve on these two! Things take an interesting turn, however, when Natalie invites her stepmom Lexi to join in for a threesome. It's a wild suggestion, but Lexi can't help but eventually give in to temptation... having a steamy sex session she'll never forget.